Katherine Fischer Taylor

Biography

Katherine Fischer Taylor teaches the history of architecture and urbanism in western Europe and the U.S. from the Enlightenment to the present. She has taught at the University of Chicago since her PhD work at Harvard University. Her training includes a year at the former Institute for Architecture and Urban Studies in New York.

Taylor’s publications explore the social use and reception of buildings, particularly government buildings such as courthouses. Interested in architecture and the public, she wrote her dissertation on the modernization of the ancient Paris courthouse between 1835 and World War I, which she interpreted as a continually updated portrait of the evolving post-revolutionary French judicial system, against the grain of traditional French legal history. Based on her rediscovery of thousands of drawings, the study reconstructs the campaign, which mixed renovation, restoration, and new construction, in its legal context. It is summarized in her chapter, “Le Code et l’équité. La transformation du Palais de Justice de Paris au XIXe siècle” in La Justice en ses temples, 1992. Her thematic book, In the Theater of Criminal Justice: The Palais de Justice in Second Empire Paris, 1993, analyzes the dynamics and politics of criminal justice relative to their setting in a new criminal wing opened in 1868. Examining the use of the building from the varied perspectives of a range of actors from professionals to jury and public spectators at a major, contemporaneous trial, it broadens the interpretation of architecture by treating social performance as the reception of buildings by people unschooled in architecture. The book won the Society of Architectural Historians’ Spiro Kostof Award. Taylor adapted this approach to the early history of the dissimilar American judicial system and its architecture in her chapter, “First Appearances: the Material Setting and Culture of the Early Supreme Court” in The Supreme Court of the United States, 2009.

Further studies analyze how the political status of justice affects its architecture. Her chapter, “The Festival of Justice: Paris, 1849,” in Law and the Image, 1999, studies a unique ceremony to demonstrate the intertwining of two controversies: the proper architectural relationship between the expanding courthouse and the famous Gothic Sainte-Chapelle within its boundaries, and the proper political relationship between justice and the state after the Revolution of 1848, when the government purged the judiciary. A new article, “The Unanticipated Politics of Heritage in 1830s France: A Walk-In Diorama at the Supreme Court,” interprets one of the first polychrome restorations of a historic interior in France, the late medieval entrance corridor of the French supreme court in 1833, documenting its importance to the restoration of the Sainte-Chapelle and showing how the restored interior changed the judiciary’s view of its institution and contributed to a new law increasing the court’s political autonomy.

Taylor’s current project is a book-length study of the changing relationship among the executive, legislative, and judicial authorities in France from the 1780s, shortly before the Revolution of 1789, to the 1830s. It asks how the replacement of absolutist monarchy by a separation of governmental powers with a new definition of sovereignty affected the government’s different architectural settings and the way they were used. One component is her 2013 article, “Geometries of Power: Royal, Revolutionary, and Postrevolutionary French Courtrooms," which reconstructs the patterns and historical significance of different courtroom layouts—diamond-shaped, square, circular, and rectangular. She is now studying the difference of legislative settings and culture from their judicial counterparts, including the vexed use of legislatures as sites of state trials.

Taylor’s interests are also methodological. She has written on the status of architecture in art history departments (“Architecture’s Place in Art History: Art or Adjunct?” 2001) and on the unwitting practice of visual culture across disciplines in the university (Looking to Learn: Visual Pedagogy at the University of Chicago, exhibition catalog with Linda Seidel and students, 1998), and has served as a conference session respondent on the use of Foucault and Habermas and on performativity in architectural history.

Publications

In the Theater of Criminal Justice: The Palais De Justice in Second Empire Paris

Princeton University Press
,
1993

 

“The Unanticipated Politics of Heritage in 1830s France: A Walk-In Diorama at the Supreme Court,” Art Bulletin 100 (June 2018): 94-124.

,

“Geometries of Power: Royal, Revolutionary, and Postrevolutionary French Courtrooms,” Journal of the Society of Architectural Historians 72 (2013)

,

First Appearances: the Material Setting and Culture of the Early Supreme Court,” in The Supreme Court of the United States: The Pursuit of Justice, ed. Christopher Tomlins (Boston: Houghton-Mifflin, 2005)

,

The Festival of Justice: Paris, 1849, in Law and the Image, eds. Costas Douzinas & Lynda Nead (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1999)

,

Looking to Learn: Visual Pedagogy at the University of Chicago,” co-authored with Linda Seidel, Exhibition catalog (Chicago: Smart Museum of Art, University of Chicago, 1998)

,

“Le Code et l’équité. La transformation du Palais de Justice de Paris au XIXe siècle,” in La Justice en ses temples. Regards sur l’architecture judiciaire en France, eds. Association française pour l’histoire de la justice (Poitiers & Paris: Brissaud, 1992)

,

“Nature morte, 1927,” Oppositions Special issue on Le Corbusier 15/16 (1979)

,

Profiles

Charles Cohen
Charles Cohen
Italian Renaissance and Mannerist Art
CWAC 258
773.702.0619
Potters Wheel
Richard Neer
Ancient Greek Art and Architecture
CWAC 259
773.702.5890
Andrei Pop
Andrei Pop
Modern Art and Aesthetics
1130 East 59th Street
773.702.8410
Megan Sullivan
Megan Sullivan
Modern and Contemporary Latin American Art
CWAC 272
773.702.5126